Broken roof tile replacement swaps a damaged tile for a sound one of the same profile. On this Auckland job, two concrete tiles had broken and left a hole open to the roof space. We removed the damaged tiles and replaced them with matching tiles. Our published price for a single tile replacement is $150–$350 + GST.
Broken roof tile replacement means taking out a tile that has cracked through or broken apart and fitting a sound tile of the same profile in its place. This post follows one job in Auckland. Two concrete tiles had broken and left a hole open to the roof space. Here is what we found, how we replaced the tiles, and what the repair costs.
What is broken roof tile replacement?
Broken roof tile replacement is a small, local repair. A roofer removes only the damaged tiles and fits new ones, and the rest of the roof stays as it is. It is part of our tile roofing service in Auckland, which also covers ridge re-pointing, re-bedding and full tile re-roofing.
Broken roof tile replacement suits a roof whose other tiles are still sound. Where many tiles have failed, the answer changes. Our concrete tile roof repair guide covers the wider repairs a tile roof can need.
What did we find on this Auckland roof?
The roof is concrete tile. Two tiles in one course had broken into pieces. One piece had slipped down the roof, and the others sat loose and out of line.
Behind them was a hole straight into the roof space. In the photo below you can see a timber batten at the top of the opening. Below it, the inside of the roof space is in plain view.
We do not know what broke these tiles, so we do not guess. The job record does not say, and a photo cannot show it. What the photo does show is the result: rain could fall straight into the roof through this gap.
Why does a broken roof tile matter?
A tile roof sheds water because each tile overlaps the one below it. Take one tile away and that overlap is gone. Water then lands on whatever sits under the tiles.
On this roof, that was the roof space itself. Anything inside the roof can then get wet in the next spell of rain. If a ceiling has already started to sag, read our guide on what to do when a ceiling bulges with water first.
BRANZ, the building research organisation, publishes a repair guide for clay and concrete tile roofs. Its summary on MBIE’s Building CodeHub puts the point in one line.
“Regular checks and proper maintenance are critical to keep the roof in sound condition and to keep the water out.”
BRANZ Good Repair Guide: Clay and concrete roof tiles, as summarised on Building CodeHub
How did we replace the broken tiles?
This broken roof tile replacement followed three steps, and each one is simple to check on your own quote.
- We removed the damaged roof tiles. The broken pieces came out, along with any loose fragments lying on the tiles below.
- We replaced them with matching tiles. The new tiles have the same profile as the old ones, so they lock into the tiles on each side.
- We restored a watertight finish. The new tiles sit under the course above and over the course below, as the original tiles did.
The photo above shows the same spot after the work. The hole is closed. The two new tiles line up with the tiles beside them, and the course above overlaps them.
Why do the new tiles look a different colour?
Because they are new. The two replacement tiles on this roof are darker and bluer than the tiles around them. The older tiles have weathered to a brown-grey over their years on the roof.
Profile comes first in broken roof tile replacement. A tile that does not lock into its neighbours leaves a gap, however good the colour looks. Colour is the second question. Our guide to matching replacement roof tiles explains where replacement tiles come from and how roofers blend them in.
What does a second job look like?
Broken roof tile replacement looks much the same on every tile roof. Here is a second Auckland job. In the first photo, the old tile is being lifted out by hand. Its surface is stained orange-brown, like the tiles beside it.
In the second photo, the replacement tile is in place. It is darker than the stained tiles on either side, and it sits under the course above.
How do the two jobs compare?
| What the photos show | First job | Second job |
|---|---|---|
| The damage | Two broken tiles and a hole open to the roof space | One old tile lifted out of its course |
| The repair | Two matching replacement tiles | One replacement tile |
| Colour of the new tiles | Darker and bluer than the weathered tiles | Darker than the stained tiles beside it |
| The rest of the roof | Left as it was | Left as it was |
Can you replace a broken roof tile yourself?
We recommend against it, for two reasons. The first is the roof. Consumer NZ’s guide to general roof maintenance warns that tiles do not like foot traffic.
“Old asbestos roofs and clay and concrete tiles can be damaged when walked on so wear soft soled shoes with good grip.”
Consumer NZ, General roof maintenance
So a careless repair can break more tiles than it fixes. Our post on roof walking damage shows how that happens.
The second reason is you. The same guide says that on a roof over 15 degrees in pitch, “you generally have little or no chance of catching yourself before the edge if you slip.” WorkSafe New Zealand’s working-at-height guidance explains the risks in full.
What should you do when you spot a broken tile?
- Stay off the roof. Look from the ground, or from a window that faces the roof.
- Take a photo, so you can show a roofer where the damage is.
- Check the ceiling under that part of the roof for stains or damp patches.
- Put a bucket under any drip, and move what you can out of the way.
- Book an inspection. Ask the roofer to check the tiles around the broken one too.
Not sure whether your tile is broken or only cracked? Our guide to cracked roof tile repair or replacement explains how a roofer decides.
If rain is forecast and a hole is open, a temporary cover may be the first job. Our temporary roof tarping guide explains how that works.
How much does broken roof tile replacement cost in Auckland?
Our published price for a single tile or cracked cap replacement in Auckland is $150–$350 + GST. Most roof repairs cost $150–$1,800 + GST. Three things move the price: how easy the roof is to reach, the tile profile, and how many tiles are broken.
We do not publish the price of the jobs in this post. We confirm the price for your roof in a written quote, after a free inspection.
Book a free roof inspection or call 022 501 9921, and tell us where the broken tile is.
What Questions Do Auckland Homeowners Ask?
Can a single broken roof tile be replaced?
Yes. A roofer lifts the tiles that overlap the broken one, takes the broken tile out and slides a tile of the same profile into its place. On our Auckland job, we replaced two broken concrete tiles this way. The rest of the roof stayed as it was, because the tiles around the hole were still sound.
How much does broken roof tile replacement cost in Auckland?
Our published price for a single tile or cracked cap replacement in Auckland is $150–$350 + GST. Most roof repairs cost $150–$1,800 + GST. The price for your roof depends on access, the tile profile and how many tiles are broken. We confirm it in a written quote after a free inspection.
Is a broken roof tile an emergency?
Treat it as urgent when you can see a hole, or when water is coming through the ceiling. A broken tile leaves the layers under it open to rain. If the tile is cracked but still in place, book an inspection soon. Call us on 022 501 9921 if water is already getting inside.
Will the new roof tile match the old ones?
The profile must match, because roof tiles interlock with their neighbours. The colour often does not match at first. On our Auckland job, the two new tiles are darker and bluer than the weathered tiles around them. Ask your roofer where the replacement tiles will come from before the work starts.
Can I replace a broken roof tile myself?
We recommend against it. Replacing a tile means working at height on a surface that breaks underfoot. Consumer NZ warns that clay and concrete tiles can be damaged when walked on. WorkSafe New Zealand publishes guidance on working at height. A roofer also checks the layers under the tile, which you cannot judge from a ladder.
Topics covered
- roof tile replacement Auckland
- replacing roof tiles
- replace a broken roof tile
- broken concrete roof tile
- roof tile replacement cost
